11.10 am, Sunday November 22 2009

Labor veterans remember The Dismissal

16:23 AEST Fri Nov 11 2005
AAP
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far

Rage has given way to ridicule as Labor luminaries marked the 30th anniversary of Sir John Kerr's sacking of the Whitlam government.

Gough Whitlam, now 89, mocked the late governor-general's taste for the trappings of office - the top hat "one size too small", the morning suit bedecked with ribbons and gongs - and referred to his second wife, the late Lady Anne, as "fancy Nancy".

Mr Whitlam said the Kerrs were also privately held in contempt by Malcolm Fraser, the Liberal leader Sir John installed as caretaker prime minister, and Mr Fraser's wife Tamie.

The Kerrs were "figures of ridicule still", Mr Whitlam said, underlining an earlier observation that Sir John had exactly the same books as his predecessor in the Yarralumla library, with one addition - Debrett's Peerage, the guide to the British aristocracy.

Former prime minister Paul Keating, one of Mr Whitlam's junior ministers in 1975, took up the theme this week when he derided Sir John as a "pumped-up bunyip potentate" who heard voices about his own self-importance.

Former NSW Premier Bob Carr chimed in: "Living in the gilded cage of Admiralty House (in Sydney) and Government House at Yarralumla, being attended to by security chiefs, ambassadors and visiting heads of state, created the illusion in this man that the paper role of governor-general had a reality."

Mr Whitlam and Mr Fraser still disagree about the rights and wrongs of Australia's greatest constitutional crisis.

Mr Whitlam maintains Sir John had no right to deceive him and "conspire" to dismiss a democratically-elected prime minister.

Mr Fraser insists he had the right to use the opposition's senate majority to block money supply bills and force the government to an election, which Mr Fraser subsequently won with a crushing majority.

But the two old political adversaries - Mr Whitlam once dubbed Mr Fraser "Kerr's cur" - have found much common ground since.

"He's vastly improved," Mr Whitlam told an interviewer.

"There is no difference between us now that I can detect in any matter of international or regional affairs or human rights."

Mr Fraser said he had always admired Mr Whitlam's grand ideas, and "quite apart from that I enjoy Gough's company".

Mr Whitlam, along with current Labor leader Kim Beazley, has called for the constitution to be changed to prevent the senate ever again blocking supply bills.

But Prime Minister John Howard rejected the idea.

He also sprang to Sir John Kerr's defence, saying Mr Whitlam's dismissal was not the fault of Sir John or the constitution but the product of a clash of political wills.

"This retrospective attempt to paint John Kerr as the dark evil-doer of terrible deeds has been so unfair and one of the great historical distortions of my life," Mr Howard said.

"I think it's been one of the great injustices of Australian history that John Kerr, whose fate it was to resolve a deadlock he did not create, that he has been so savagely maligned by history.

"And I think the continued personal invective and spleen against a dead man which is engaged in by people who should know better is quite depressing."

Mr Whitlam once famously told his supporters to maintain the rage, but Labor frontbencher Lindsay Tanner said it was time to relinquish the rage.

"For most people under 45 it (the dismissal) is an obscure item of history," he said.

"We need to celebrate it but get it in perspective, and I think that 30 years is long enough.

"It's time we got over it."

 
SHARE:
MESSENGER
FACEBOOK
MORE
Blog on Spaces
Add to delicious
Add to Digg
Share on MySpace
?
Share, bookmark, and save your favourite ninemsn articles and features.  Learn more.

Most popular

 Demi furious at Photoshop claimsDemi Moore has reacted with fury at allegations her body was badly 'enhanced' by a fashion magazine.
 One dead as Miley Cyrus tour bus crashesThe driver of a Miley Cyrus tour bus has died and one passenger has been injured after the vehicle veered off the road and flipped over in Virginia.
 Barmaid claims she had sex with SA premierA former parliament house barmaid has come forward claiming she had a sexual relationship with South Australian Premier Mike Rann.
 Twins' birth mum wants daughters to stayThe birth mother of twins Krishna and Trishna who gave them up due to poverty says she wants them to remain in Australia to be educated.
 Spears' ex-boyfriend sentenced to jailBritney Spears' ex-boyfriend Adnan Ghalib is being sent to jail for 45 days for leaving the scene of an accident.
 Departing Oprah problem for TV stationsOprah Winfrey will leave a huge void for broadcast TV in 2011, even as she raises the possibility of more Oprah than ever when she starts her own cable network.
 Kim Watkins' future at Ten uncertainThe future career of morning television host Kim Watkins is uncertain, with Network Ten unable to say if she'll return in 2010.
 Norfolk pilot 'flew without enough fuel'The pilot hailed a hero for ditching his plane safely off Norfolk Island this week may have been dangerously negligent after reportedly making the journey without enough fuel.
 Judge dismisses Cyrus 'slant eyes' suitA US judge has dismissed a lawsuit against Miley Cyrus which accused her of discriminating against Asians after she was photographed making "slant eyes".
 British poll reveals sexual ignoranceMore than one in 10 British people don't realise that a woman can still get pregnant if she has sex standing up, according to a poll on Friday.
Amanda Knox at her trial. (AAP)'Harboured hate'Prosecutor sums up murder case against student Amanda Knox. In for the long haul... don't forget activity bag! (Getty Images)Trouble-free tripsTRAVEL: How to plan a family adventure without the pain. A happy fan gets his copy of Modern Warfare. (AAP)Bloody bonanzaModern Warfare 2 rakes in over $500 million in its first week. AAPBad energyIs there a connection between mobile phones and cancer? ACAChurch slammedAussie senator brands Scientology a 'criminal organisation'. Schoolies celebrations on the Gold Coast. (AAP)Schoolies swipeCalls for drinking age to be lifted to 19 ahead of annual teen party.
advertisement
Entourage death Miley Cyrus's driver killed, another injured after tour bus overturns ... read more Running on empty Cleo bachelor pilot reportedly made journey without enough fuel ... read more 'Worst Photoshop ever' Demi Moore's hip deformed in Photoshop disaster ... read more Sickest stunt Furious hackers track down man who hurled dog off bridge and posted video online ... read more Stuck in chair for eight months 365kg man dies after being stuck in a recliner chair for months ... read more Hair dye horror Teenage girl's face 'turns into an alien' after a botched hair dye job ... read more Become a Nine News breaker Seen or heard something? Send tip-offs, images and video from your mobile or PC ... contact us
Top model mournedFriends say rising young model found dead in Paris flat was 'full of creativity'
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete
Other ninemsn businesses: iSelect RateCity
© 1997-2009 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved