07.28 pm, Monday February 13 2012

Turnbull faces backbench revolt

Thursday, June 25, 2009
By Julian Drape and Melissa Jenkins
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far
Petro Georgiou
Liberal MP Petro Georgiou is supporting Labor's plan to scrap detention fees for asylum seekers.

Also on
Firing lineDad's Facebook revenge Diva diesPrescription pills found in room babyliciousBeyonce shows off baby pub attackMan cut with chainsaw youthfulHow old are the stars, really? teen dreamDo Valentine's with Bieber

Federal Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull's leadership was further undermined on Wednesday amid the second backbench revolt in a week.

Liberal backbenchers Petro Georgiou, Judi Moylan, Danna Vale and Russell Broadbent plan to cross the floor to vote with the government on its legislation abolishing the practice of billing asylum seekers for their mandatory detention.

Mr Georgiou, who will retire at the next election, fought back tears as he told parliament on Wednesday that no advanced society should charge innocent people for the cost of their incarceration.

"Do we make major drug dealers, serial pedophiles, sadistic murderers or multiple rapists pay the costs of their incarceration?" he said.

"The answer is that we do not."

The dissent comes after four coalition MPs on Monday night defied their leader to vote against the government's 70 per cent alcopops tax hike. Nationals leader in the Senate Barnaby Joyce says he won't turn up for the upper house vote, and colleague Fiona Nash has also said she won't support the bill.

Coalition MPs have been directed to vote against the government bill that aims to abolish the policy of charging asylum seekers for their detention.

Detainees can face debts totalling more than $45,000 for each year of incarceration.

The legislation also waives existing debts for current and former detainees, but it won't refund any debts already paid.

Ms Moylan also fired a salvo at her coalition colleagues who oppose the bill.

"I have to say that I am extremely disappointed that, once again, politics are played at the expense of some of the world's most vulnerable people," she said.

"I don't think these are the kind of people that we need to further punish.

"I think they've been punished enough."

Opposition immigration spokeswoman Sharman Stone said that since the Labor government changed its immigration policy in August, 22 illegal boats had been intercepted carrying more than 900 asylum seekers, including a vessel off Ashmore Reef that was discovered on Tuesday.

"There is no doubt that announcing to the region that the Rudd Labor regime is abolishing the 17-year-old policy ... will bring great joy to people smugglers who are once again very active in our waters," she said.

"We can't support further watering down of border protection policy and the integrity of our humanitarian refugee program."

Queensland Liberal Stuart Robert quoted former prime minister John Howard in his speech, saying: "We should continue to decide who comes to this country and the circumstances in which they come".

Debate on the Migration Amendment (Abolishing Detention Debt) Bill 2009 was adjourned.

 
Whitney Houston. (AAP)Golden years VIDEO: A look back at Whitney Houston's glittering career. Whitney Houston sings onstage.Last performance VIDEO: Houston takes to the stage for impromptu song. A man wields a chainsaw in England.Chainsaw attack VIDEO: English man goes on rampage, destroying pub. A young avalanche survivor.Lone survivor VIDEO: Girl pulled from rubble 10 hours after quake. A US judge dozes in court.Dozing in court VIDEO: US judge caught sleeping behind the bench. Mercedes Maybach (AAP)Fancy flopMercedes Benz's Maybach mistake keeps on costing

Most popular

 Katy Perry fools Grammys audienceKaty Perry pulled a cheeky stunt to fool viewers into believing a technical disaster had struck midway through her Grammys performance.
 Blue Mountains lashed by heavy hailThe Blue Mountains has been lashed by heavy hail and rainfall, with one resident saying it was "like it was snowing".
 Dad, daughter reach 'truce' after laptop shootingThe US father who made a video of himself reading out his daughter’s Facebook post before shooting her laptop says she initially broke down but they have now reached a "semi-truce".
 NSW man found dead at Japan ski resortThe body of a 45-year-old Australian on skiing trip has been found in a creek in the Japanese ski resort of Niseko.
 Induced labour lets dying man see daughterAn American woman has had her labour induced so her husband could see their baby girl before he died.
 Dog beheader mentally ill, court toldA man accused of beheading a woman's dog was mentally ill, a Gold Coast court heard.
 Body in Sydney tree identifiedPolice have identified the woman whose body was found in a Sydney tree last month as a US national.
 Rihanna shouts out high-energy Houston tributePop star Rihanna turned her Grammy Awards performance into a high-energy, foot-stomping tribute to music icon Whitney Houston.
 Harvey doesn't want dogs put down after attackNine News reporter Peter Harvey says he does not blame the bulldogs that attacked him while walking in Sydney's Centennial Park yesterday.
 British rapist loses deportation appealRapist Leslie Cunliffe, whose crime was described as something out Silence of the Lambs, has lost an appeal against his deportation to the UK.
advertisement
Be our fan on Facebook
Most Recommended
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete