03.58 pm, Monday November 23 2009

Garrett's beds are burning: critics

22:13 AEST Wed Jul 15 2009
By Cathy Alexander and Larine Statham
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far
Peter Garrett
Peter Garrett has been accused of losing credibility with his decision to approve a uranium mine.

Federal Environment Minister Peter Garrett appears to have alienated another group he made his name singing about - indigenous people.

Mr Garrett sang about the need to make amends to Aborigines in his smash hit song Beds are burning.

"The time has come, a fact's a fact, it belongs to them, let's give it back," runs the chorus.

But as environment minister he's singing a different tune.

Mr Garrett has approved a new uranium mine for South Australia - and some traditional owners aren't happy.

They are worried about their land "being raped by mining companies" and have called for the approval for the Four Mile mine to be deferred.

Adnyamathanha elder Enice Marsh has asked the SA and federal governments for an independent investigation into the Aboriginal heritage of the Four Mile site.

"What more can we do to protect our land from being raped by mining companies that are allowed to pollute the water and carve up the waterways, even contaminate the soil with radioactive waste?" Ms Marsh said.

"Aboriginal people have no rights under Native Title to protect our heritage."

Mr Garrett told reporters that approving the mine had not let down Aboriginal people.

"In fact, there is an agreement between traditional owners and Aboriginal people in South Australia and the proponents on this matter," he said.

"And I expect that Aboriginal communities will receive benefits as a consequence of the decision that has been taken."

Mr Garrett answered criticism from the Greens and the Coalition that he had sold out his principles in approving the mine.

"Look, that is an old song," he said.

"I approve a lot of decisions right around Australia and Australians can be confident that when Peter Garrett is the environment minister he will make sure that the environmental standards are the highest that they can be and that they need to be."

Meanwhile, nuclear advocates have used the booming uranium industry to call for a domestic nuclear power industry.

The number of Australian uranium mines will rise from three to five next year but none of the yellowcake will be used to generate electricity here.

Clarence Hardy, the secretary of the Australian Nuclear Association, said it was time to use the uranium domestically.

"We consider it's really ironic that the present government is very happy to export uranium to overseas countries for nuclear power but it just won't consider it in Australia," Dr Hardy said.

"It's what I call hypocritical."

Ian Duncan, the former chief of the world's pro-nuclear association, which is now called the World Nuclear Association, echoed the support for nuclear power.

He said it would cost $6 billion to $8 billion and take a decade to build a nuclear power station here.

It would create 600 ongoing jobs, last for 40 years, and generate clean electricity with virtually no greenhouse gas emissions, Dr Duncan said.

"It's time that we moved along from the caveman attitude of just picking it up and burning things. We should move to a higher order of source of energy," he said.

 
SHARE:
MESSENGER
FACEBOOK
MORE
Blog on Spaces
Add to delicious
Add to Digg
Share on MySpace
?
Share, bookmark, and save your favourite ninemsn articles and features.  Learn more.

Most popular

 Demi furious at Photoshop claimsDemi Moore has reacted with fury at allegations her body was badly 'enhanced' by a fashion magazine.
 One dead as Miley Cyrus tour bus crashesThe driver of a Miley Cyrus tour bus has died and one passenger has been injured after the vehicle veered off the road and flipped over in Virginia.
 Barmaid claims she had sex with SA premierA former parliament house barmaid has come forward claiming she had a sexual relationship with South Australian Premier Mike Rann.
 Twins' birth mum wants daughters to stayThe birth mother of twins Krishna and Trishna who gave them up due to poverty says she wants them to remain in Australia to be educated.
 Spears' ex-boyfriend sentenced to jailBritney Spears' ex-boyfriend Adnan Ghalib is being sent to jail for 45 days for leaving the scene of an accident.
 Departing Oprah problem for TV stationsOprah Winfrey will leave a huge void for broadcast TV in 2011, even as she raises the possibility of more Oprah than ever when she starts her own cable network.
 Kim Watkins' future at Ten uncertainThe future career of morning television host Kim Watkins is uncertain, with Network Ten unable to say if she'll return in 2010.
 Norfolk pilot 'flew without enough fuel'The pilot hailed a hero for ditching his plane safely off Norfolk Island this week may have been dangerously negligent after reportedly making the journey without enough fuel.
 Judge dismisses Cyrus 'slant eyes' suitA US judge has dismissed a lawsuit against Miley Cyrus which accused her of discriminating against Asians after she was photographed making "slant eyes".
 British poll reveals sexual ignoranceMore than one in 10 British people don't realise that a woman can still get pregnant if she has sex standing up, according to a poll on Friday.
ninemsn newsroom reader Wendy Kingston. (Nine News)Newsroom latest A quick hit of the top stories making news online today. Bollywood actress Shilpa Shetty has tied the knot. (Getty)Bollywood bashIndian actress Shilpa Shetty marries in lavish ceremony. Michelle Chantelois says she had an affair with Mike Rann. (Seven Network)Sex claimsBarmaid says she got intimate with premier 'on parliament desk'. AAPWild Lily Lily Allen shocks Ray Martin with her plans for the future. ACASolo manHero from classic 80s TV ads tells of his latest adventures. Canadian woman Nathalie Blanchard's benefits were cut.Bikini bustWoman loses insurance benefits over Facebook photos.
advertisement
Top model mourned Fashion star found dead in apartment was full of creativity, friends say ... read more Movie monster Twilight sequel has highest-grossing opening day of all time ... read more Entourage death Miley Cyrus's driver killed, another injured after tour bus overturns ... read more Zoo bear attacks A man has been mauled after climbing a zoo wall and falling into a bear enclosure ... read more Snapper hits back The photographer at the centre of the Demi Moore photoshop scandal speaks out ... read more Ride from hell Commuters get trapped in a train carriage with an alleged killer and body ... read more Become a Nine News breaker Seen or heard something? Send tip-offs, images and video from your mobile or PC ... contact us
Ugly accoladeControversial Melbourne landmark labelled one of world's worst buildings
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete
Other ninemsn businesses: iSelect RateCity
© 1997-2009 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved