04.06 am, Friday May 25 2012

Take heat out of boat arrivals debate: UN

15:42 AEDT Tue Feb 14 2012
Isabel Hayes
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far
Also on
Fake filmTeen suspended over bullying vid No chuteDaredevil leaps from helicopter Tipping overTruck filmed losing control 'Too hot'Woman 'fired for good looks' confessionKelly cites Scientology bunny timeKate Upton hits the bikini beach

The debate on boat arrivals to Australia needs to be much calmer and a lot less polarised, the head of the UN's refugee agency says.

Australia's intake of 6000 asylum seekers a year is not a big problem compared to the intake of other countries, UN High Commissioner for Refugees, Antonio Guterres, told the Lowy Institute in Sydney on Tuesday.

"Compared to the refugee problems in other regions of the world, it is my belief that this debate has been very politicised and is out of proportion ... as the number of people coming to Australia are small by world standards," Mr Guterres said.

"States have the right and indeed the obligation to manage their borders responsibly but this needs to be valued in a way that is protection sensitive and does not preclude those who need protection from seeking it.

"... I would prefer the debate to be much calmer and much less polarised as I witness it is in Australia."

Mr Guterres is in Australia for talks with the government and the opposition, with mandatory detention and onshore processing central to the discussions.

He said he had expressed his concerns about mandatory detention and the effects it has on asylum seekers with the government.

"National security concerns might justify a limited period in which the movement of asylum seekers needs to be controlled," Mr Guterres said.

"Nonetheless, the negative impact that prolonged mandatory detention has on these people is well known and documented."

He welcomed the government's move to release some asylum seekers, including children, into the community on bridging visas and he praised the "clear, positive efforts towards multiculturalism" in Australia.

"We cannot reduce our relationship to the discussion of the boat people," Mr Guterres said.

He pointed to Australia's high support for humanitarian aid, its resettlement program which is the biggest per capita in the world and its "extremely successful reintegration policy to those refugees in Australia".

"Fears about rejected floods of refugees in industrialised countries are often vastly overblown ... and those fears can all too easily manifest into statements or acts of xenophobia against foreigners," he said.

"With that in mind, I encourage all of those involved in public discourse in this country to approach the issue of refugees and asylum seekers with a sense of balance, perspective and compassion for those who are less fortunate."

 

Most popular

 Baby died in hot car as mum slept: courtThe 21-year-old Melbourne mother charged with manslaughter over the death of her baby daughter in a hot car has been granted bail.
 Child prostitution ring ran for 2 yearsMore victims may come forward and more arrests are expected from an investigation into a Sydney child prostitution ring.
 UK girl with bow hairstyle banned from photoAn English four-year-old was banned from appearing in her annual school photograph because her hair had been styled in a bow.
 Bear attacks Canadian man on toiletA 65-year-old man has told how he was dragged off a toilet by a black bear while on a camping trip in Canada.
 Drowned chef's friends 'will suffer entire lives'A young Melbourne man who drowned after jumping off a pier early this morning had been drinking with friends who convinced him to take the fatal plunge.
 Brisbane man collapses after crashing MonaroA Brisbane man collapsed after seeing his pride and joy, a Holden Monaro, burst into flames after colliding with a traffic island this morning.
 Wife caught husband in bed with teenA man's drug-fuelled relationship with a child was exposed when his wife caught them in bed together, a court has heard.
 Unexploded bomb found in Ballarat museumVisitors to a country Victorian museum have been evacuated after the discovery of an unexploded World War I egg bomb.
 Grieving pit bull stays by dead friendA heartbreaking photo has been posted online of a grieving pit bull staying by the side of its friend after it was hit by a car on a US street.
 Mum finds penis drawing inside burger boxA Queensland mother who received a Hungry Jack's burger with a crudely drawn penis inside its packaging said she was so disgusted it left her feeling physically ill.
Be our fan on Facebook
Most Recommended
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete