07.49 am, Friday May 25 2012
Queensland flood disaster

Qld dam diary too time consuming: engineer

19:13 AEDT Sun Feb 5 2012
By Darren Cartwright
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far
3000 seeking Queensland floods compensation3000 seeking Queensland floods compensation Man ordered to remove flood hit yachtMan ordered to remove flood hit yacht Flood inquiry hearings extendedFlood inquiry hearings extended Insurance bosses to front inquiryInsurance bosses to front inquiry

An engineer has told the Queensland floods inquiry that keeping a contemporary record of water release strategies was "too time consuming".

But engineers are now following that practice and logging water-release strategies as flood events unfold.

Terry Malone, who was the third of four engineers to appear before the reopened inquiry at the Brisbane Magistrates Court, spent all but about 10 minutes on the stand on Sunday.

The final engineer to front the hearing, John Ruffini, answered only a few questions before the hearing was adjourned until 9am (AEST) on Monday.

Mr Malone said no run sheets detailing the exact time water-release strategies were activated last January were kept.

He said keeping a log on whether a low release (W1), transitional (W2) or a higher release strategy (W3) was being activated was difficult, since switching between each stage was a gradual process.

"It's not something we consciously think of in `oh, no we are moving from one strategy to another'. It's a gradual change," Mr Malone told the inquiry.

"It gets very messy if you write down `we are in W3, but my primary objectives have been met, therefore I will look at bridges'.

"We just don't do that. It's just too time consuming."

Mr Malone said an up-to-date run sheet is now being used at Wivenhoe Dam.

"It's not something we have done in the past, but it's a practice we are going to do in the future," Mr Malone said.

He said technical terms used for each water release strategy meant little, if anything, to anyone except the dam's operators until after Brisbane and Ipswich flooded.

Mr Malone even questioned if the State's Water Minister Stephen Robertson knew the difference between a W1 and a W3 release at the time.

"The use of strategies W1, W2, W3, W4, I would suggest that very little knew outside of the flood operation centre," Mr Malone said.

"I doubt whether he (Mr Robertson) would have understood what it was anyway."

He said the dam operators did the best they could in trying times.

"I believe we achieved the best possible outcome for the people of Brisbane," Mr Malone told the inquiry.

In another twist, Mr Malone admitted joking about signing his house over to his wife if a peer review of a dam operation report was bad.

Mr Malone's email exchange was with colleague John Tibaldi, who took the stand on day one, after he had informed him of "good news" about a peer review.

"Thanks for the advice as I was just about to sign the house over to my wife's name," Mr Malone wrote in the email the inquiry heard.

He said the email reply was in jest as he had no concerns about the report being anything but favourable.

The inquiry has been reopened to investigate allegations that the four engineers who controlled Wivenhoe Dam botched the water releases, caused unnecessary flooding and misled the inquiry over what strategies they employed.

It is also attempting to establish what water-release strategy was actually in use during the days before Brisbane and Ipswich flooded in the face of conflicting evidence as to which one was being used and when they were activated.

Two further days of hearings have been announced.

Justice Cate Holmes said counsel's final submissions would be made on Monday and Tuesday week, bringing to 11 the number of extra sitting days.

However, she said extending the hearing days would not affect her handing down the final report on March 16 - eight days before the state election.

 

Most popular

 Baby died in hot car as mum slept: courtThe 21-year-old Melbourne mother charged with manslaughter over the death of her baby daughter in a hot car has been granted bail.
 Child prostitution ring ran for 2 yearsMore victims may come forward and more arrests are expected from an investigation into a Sydney child prostitution ring.
 UK girl with bow hairstyle banned from photoAn English four-year-old was banned from appearing in her annual school photograph because her hair had been styled in a bow.
 Bear attacks Canadian man on toiletA 65-year-old man has told how he was dragged off a toilet by a black bear while on a camping trip in Canada.
 Drowned chef's friends 'will suffer entire lives'A young Melbourne man who drowned after jumping off a pier early this morning had been drinking with friends who convinced him to take the fatal plunge.
 Brisbane man collapses after crashing MonaroA Brisbane man collapsed after seeing his pride and joy, a Holden Monaro, burst into flames after colliding with a traffic island this morning.
 Wife caught husband in bed with teenA man's drug-fuelled relationship with a child was exposed when his wife caught them in bed together, a court has heard.
 Unexploded bomb found in Ballarat museumVisitors to a country Victorian museum have been evacuated after the discovery of an unexploded World War I egg bomb.
 Grieving pit bull stays by dead friendA heartbreaking photo has been posted online of a grieving pit bull staying by the side of its friend after it was hit by a car on a US street.
 Mum finds penis drawing inside burger boxA Queensland mother who received a Hungry Jack's burger with a crudely drawn penis inside its packaging said she was so disgusted it left her feeling physically ill.
Be our fan on Facebook
Most Recommended
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete